3-year follow-up of Munich Psychotherapy Study supports longer treatments morgana build | psykodynamiskt.nu
All posts Research Diagnostic Meta Studies Naturalistic research morgana build Process Research RCT Other psychodynamic research reviews Therapy Methods Affect phobia therapy Extension Based Family Therapy for Children and Adolescents therapies Dynamic deconstructive psychotherapy Dynamic interpersonal therapy Group therapy Intensive dynamic short-term psychotherapy Ment Ali Ring-Based Psychotherapy panic-focused psychodynamic psychotherapy Psychoanalytic-interactional psychotherapy Psychoanalysis Psychodynamic interpersonal psychotherapy, morgana build psychodynamic short-term therapy Psychodynamic long-term therapy Psychodynamic psychotherapy morgana build Supportive-expressive psychotherapy morgana build Transference-focused psychoterapy
Huber, D., Zimmermann, J., Henrich, G., & Klug, G. (2012). Comparison of cognitive-behavior therapy with psychoanalytic and psychodynamic therapy for depressed patient - a three-year follow-up study. Zeitschrift für Medizin und Psychosomatische Psychotherapie, 58 (3), 299-316. Retrieved from http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22987495
This has happened, morgana build we have previously written about the Munich Psychotherapy Study, an ambitious study comparing Cognitive Behavioural Therapy (CBT), psychodynamic psychotherapy (PDT) and psychoanalysis (PA) in depression.
The study is kvasirandomiserad, patients were randomized to PDT and psychoanalysis, while the CBT group for cost reasons not randomized. The study has also striven for good external validity, and therefore, among other wide exclusion. This has led to the group of patients treated was relatively congested - almost a third had a concurrent personality disorder and 48 percent had recurrent depression.
One year after treatment, 91 percent of patients who have attended psychoanalysis still free from depression, while the same was true of 76 percent of patients receiving PDT and 42 percent of patients who received CBT.
It has also taken an interest in additional to the effects of time. None of the treatments morgana build were limited but the therapists in all groups were instructed to allow treatments to be as long as they saw fit for each specific patient.
When the study was completed, there were no significant differences in scores on the BDI (Beck Depression Inventory) - however, it was seen that the group who received CBT were significantly more who still met the diagnostic morgana build criteria for depression. One year after treatment, 91 percent of patients who have attended psychoanalysis still free from depression, while the same was true of 76 percent of patients receiving PDT and 42 percent of patients who received CBT.
Additionally, you could see when you looked at measures of interpersonal functioning and structural change that psychoanalysis led to by far the most changes, with PDT in the middle, and CBT minimum. More about the first reports from the Munich Psychotherapy Study can be read here.
Monitoring While the treatment was completed and one year follow up, therefore there was no significant difference between groups in scores on the BDI, seen it for another two years, a significant difference between the group that received CBT and group with psychoanalysis, with a magnitude of effect of d = 0.67 ( p <.01) between groups. As a single morgana build group, the patients who went into psychoanalysis continued to improve on the BDI right up to the three-year follow-up - we look is a long so-called sleeper effect! PDT group deteriorated slightly while the group who received CBT deteriorated the most.
Regarding GSI (Global Severity Index) was already in previous measurements, a significant difference between the group that received CBT and group with psychoanalysis. morgana build The difference morgana build has fotsatt to increase and is now even greater. However, there was no longer any significant difference between PDT and CBT on this measure now.
Proportion of patients in remission at three-year follow-up was 83 percent in psycho-analysis group, 68% in the PDT group and 52% in the CBT group. Differences were here again significant between PA and CBT, but not between PDT and CBT.
The authors believe that one explanation for the results is to be found in the therapy dose. Lambert and Ogles (2004) found that more than 50 sessions are necessary for more than 75% of patients, that they should completely get rid of their symptoms.
The authors believe that one explanation for the results is to be found in the therapy dose. Lambert and Ogles (2004) found that more than 50 sessions are necessary for more than 75% of patients, that they should completely get rid of their symptoms. Urgent problems require fewer sessions than character issues or problems of a more chronic nature. morgana build In this study, only 13 of the 34 patients in the CBT group and only 20 of 31 patients morgana build in the PDT group over 50 sessions, while the same was true for 33 of 35 patients in psycho-analysis group. That would then be a reason why these patients did not improve in equal g
All posts Research Diagnostic Meta Studies Naturalistic research morgana build Process Research RCT Other psychodynamic research reviews Therapy Methods Affect phobia therapy Extension Based Family Therapy for Children and Adolescents therapies Dynamic deconstructive psychotherapy Dynamic interpersonal therapy Group therapy Intensive dynamic short-term psychotherapy Ment Ali Ring-Based Psychotherapy panic-focused psychodynamic psychotherapy Psychoanalytic-interactional psychotherapy Psychoanalysis Psychodynamic interpersonal psychotherapy, morgana build psychodynamic short-term therapy Psychodynamic long-term therapy Psychodynamic psychotherapy morgana build Supportive-expressive psychotherapy morgana build Transference-focused psychoterapy
Huber, D., Zimmermann, J., Henrich, G., & Klug, G. (2012). Comparison of cognitive-behavior therapy with psychoanalytic and psychodynamic therapy for depressed patient - a three-year follow-up study. Zeitschrift für Medizin und Psychosomatische Psychotherapie, 58 (3), 299-316. Retrieved from http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22987495
This has happened, morgana build we have previously written about the Munich Psychotherapy Study, an ambitious study comparing Cognitive Behavioural Therapy (CBT), psychodynamic psychotherapy (PDT) and psychoanalysis (PA) in depression.
The study is kvasirandomiserad, patients were randomized to PDT and psychoanalysis, while the CBT group for cost reasons not randomized. The study has also striven for good external validity, and therefore, among other wide exclusion. This has led to the group of patients treated was relatively congested - almost a third had a concurrent personality disorder and 48 percent had recurrent depression.
One year after treatment, 91 percent of patients who have attended psychoanalysis still free from depression, while the same was true of 76 percent of patients receiving PDT and 42 percent of patients who received CBT.
It has also taken an interest in additional to the effects of time. None of the treatments morgana build were limited but the therapists in all groups were instructed to allow treatments to be as long as they saw fit for each specific patient.
When the study was completed, there were no significant differences in scores on the BDI (Beck Depression Inventory) - however, it was seen that the group who received CBT were significantly more who still met the diagnostic morgana build criteria for depression. One year after treatment, 91 percent of patients who have attended psychoanalysis still free from depression, while the same was true of 76 percent of patients receiving PDT and 42 percent of patients who received CBT.
Additionally, you could see when you looked at measures of interpersonal functioning and structural change that psychoanalysis led to by far the most changes, with PDT in the middle, and CBT minimum. More about the first reports from the Munich Psychotherapy Study can be read here.
Monitoring While the treatment was completed and one year follow up, therefore there was no significant difference between groups in scores on the BDI, seen it for another two years, a significant difference between the group that received CBT and group with psychoanalysis, with a magnitude of effect of d = 0.67 ( p <.01) between groups. As a single morgana build group, the patients who went into psychoanalysis continued to improve on the BDI right up to the three-year follow-up - we look is a long so-called sleeper effect! PDT group deteriorated slightly while the group who received CBT deteriorated the most.
Regarding GSI (Global Severity Index) was already in previous measurements, a significant difference between the group that received CBT and group with psychoanalysis. morgana build The difference morgana build has fotsatt to increase and is now even greater. However, there was no longer any significant difference between PDT and CBT on this measure now.
Proportion of patients in remission at three-year follow-up was 83 percent in psycho-analysis group, 68% in the PDT group and 52% in the CBT group. Differences were here again significant between PA and CBT, but not between PDT and CBT.
The authors believe that one explanation for the results is to be found in the therapy dose. Lambert and Ogles (2004) found that more than 50 sessions are necessary for more than 75% of patients, that they should completely get rid of their symptoms.
The authors believe that one explanation for the results is to be found in the therapy dose. Lambert and Ogles (2004) found that more than 50 sessions are necessary for more than 75% of patients, that they should completely get rid of their symptoms. Urgent problems require fewer sessions than character issues or problems of a more chronic nature. morgana build In this study, only 13 of the 34 patients in the CBT group and only 20 of 31 patients morgana build in the PDT group over 50 sessions, while the same was true for 33 of 35 patients in psycho-analysis group. That would then be a reason why these patients did not improve in equal g
No comments:
Post a Comment